How to choose a weight loss supplement
Learn how to read a Supplement Facts panel and spot the warning signs of a risky product before you spend money on a weight loss supplement.
A weight loss supplement can look convincing on the shelf, but the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) says most supplements marketed for weight loss haven’t been proven safe or effective. To choose one, check that the Supplement Facts panel lists each ingredient’s amount, and skip proprietary blends and big promises. Then look for a third-party quality seal, read the research on the main ingredients, and ask your doctor or pharmacist about your medicines and health conditions.
Does the FDA approve weight loss supplements?
No. The FDA has no authority to approve dietary supplements before they’re marketed, and it doesn’t test them before they’re sold. Drug companies must show the FDA evidence that their drugs are safe and effective before selling them.
The supplement company is responsible for having evidence that its product is safe and that its label is truthful and not misleading. The FDA can act against an unsafe or mislabeled supplement only after it’s on the market.
How to read a supplement label
Turn the bottle around and start with the Supplement Facts panel. It must list the serving size, the number of servings per container, and each dietary ingredient. Except for ingredients in a proprietary blend, it must also give each amount per serving.
Serving size
The serving size is the most the label tells you to take at one time. If the directions say 1 to 3 tablets with breakfast, the serving size is 3 tablets.
Amount per serving and % Daily Value
Depending on the ingredient, the amount appears by weight, as a percentage of the Daily Value (% DV), or both. The label must show a % DV for every ingredient that has an FDA Daily Value. Without one, the ingredient gets a symbol that points to a footnote saying no Daily Value is established. For those ingredients, note the weight so you can compare it with the doses used in studies.
Proprietary blends
A proprietary blend groups ingredients under one name, either “Proprietary Blend” or a descriptive or made-up name. The label must give the blend’s total weight and list its ingredients from most to least by weight. It doesn’t have to show how much of each one you get.
So you can’t compare an ingredient’s dose with the doses used in studies, or tell whether the first ingredient makes up most of the blend. If the main ingredients sit inside a blend, look for a product that lists every amount.
Other ingredients
Below the panel, “other ingredients” lists substances such as fillers, binders, preservatives, sweeteners, and flavorings. Read it if you have allergies or avoid certain additives.
What label claims can and can’t tell you
A supplement label can’t say the product treats or prevents a disease, because only drugs can make those claims. Supplements can instead make structure/function claims, which describe how something affects the body’s normal structure or function. NCCIH’s example is “Calcium builds strong bones.”
Each of these claims must carry a disclaimer that begins “This statement has not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration.” The company must have evidence that its claim is truthful and not misleading.
“Natural” isn’t a safety promise either. NCCIH notes that kava, a plant in the pepper family, can cause liver disease when taken as a supplement.
What a quality seal does and doesn’t check
A seal from a third-party program, such as USP Verified or NSF, tells you the product’s contents match its label. It doesn’t mean anyone evaluated the product’s safety or whether it works.
Operation Supplement Safety, a Department of Defense program, explains that certification means an independent organization with no ties to the maker has verified the product’s quality and manufacturing process. When a company calls its own product “verified” or “certified,” NCCIH says those words don’t necessarily guarantee quality.
Warning signs of a risky weight loss product
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) says any promise of miraculous weight loss is untrue. It calls these claims false, so skip any product that makes them:
- You’ll lose weight without diet or exercise, or while eating all you want.
- You’ll lose 30 pounds in 30 days.
- The weight will stay off for good.
- It works for everyone.
- A patch or cream will make you lose weight.
Also watch for:
- Reviews and before-and-after photos offered as proof. The FTC warns that scammers write fake reviews and use stock or altered photos.
- “Free” trials, which the FTC says are often not free at all.
- Large amounts of caffeine, or caffeine-containing herbs such as guarana, which may raise your heart rate and cause abnormal heart rhythms.
NCCIH cites a 2015 study that estimated supplements lead to about 23,000 US emergency room visits a year. Many of the patients are young adults with heart problems from weight loss or energy products.
The FDA has also found weight loss products sold as supplements with hidden prescription drugs or other illegal ingredients, which can cause serious harm. The FTC says the FDA has discovered hundreds of supplements with potentially harmful drugs or chemicals not listed on the label. The FDA lists some of these products in its Health Fraud Product Database, but it can’t test every supplement, so an unlisted product isn’t automatically safe.
What the studies show, and how to check an ingredient
NCCIH reports that acai berry, bitter orange, and green tea supplements haven’t been shown to produce meaningful weight loss in studies. Many “fat burners” and appetite suppressants haven’t been tested for safety. Some ingredients that replaced ephedra, which the FDA banned from supplements in 2004 because of serious health risks, have similar side effects. Even a good study has limits, because the product you buy may differ in important ways from the one tested.
Our guide to what the research shows for common ingredients covers the main ones, and our weight loss supplement guides go further. To check an ingredient yourself:
- Read the NIH Office of Dietary Supplements fact sheet, if there is one.
- Search PubMed, the National Library of Medicine’s database of journal articles, most with a short summary.
- Check the FDA’s Dietary Supplement Ingredient Directory for what the agency has said or done about it.
In each study, check who took part, how many, for how long, and at what dose.
Questions to ask your doctor or pharmacist
Bring the label and ask:
- Could this interact with my medicines? St. John’s wort, for example, makes many medications less effective.
- Is it safe with my health conditions, including my heart?
- Has it been tested in people who are pregnant or breastfeeding? Many supplements haven’t.
- Should I stop it before surgery? Some supplements may raise the risk of bleeding or affect your response to anesthesia.
If you notice side effects, stop the supplement and contact your health care provider. You can also report them to the FDA through the Safety Reporting Portal.
A quick checklist before you buy
- Each main ingredient shows its own amount per serving.
- The label and ads promise nothing fast, effortless, or permanent, and make no disease claims.
- There’s a U.S. address or phone number on the label for reporting serious side effects, as the FDA requires.
- A third-party seal backs up the contents.
- You’ve looked up each main ingredient in an NIH fact sheet or on PubMed.
- Your doctor or pharmacist has checked it against your medicines and health conditions.
As the FTC puts it, there’s no magic way to lose weight without a sensible diet and regular exercise. Set a realistic daily target with our calorie deficit calculator, then build habits with our how to lose weight guides.
Sources
- 6 Things To Know About Dietary Supplements Marketed for Weight Loss, National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH)
- Using Dietary Supplements Wisely, National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH)
- Questions and Answers on Dietary Supplements, U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
- Dietary Supplement Labeling Guide: Chapter IV. Nutrition Labeling, U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
- The Truth Behind Weight Loss Ads, Federal Trade Commission (FTC)
- Why is Third-Party Certification Important for Dietary Supplements?, Operation Supplement Safety (OPSS), U.S. Department of Defense